“Oceanfront dinners looking out toward Alligator Reef Lighthouse.”
ReelCatch is the restaurant at Amara Cay Resort, oceanfront at mile marker 80 in Islamorada. From the outdoor tables you can see Alligator Reef Lighthouse on the horizon.
It does breakfast and dinner every day, with happy hour from 4 to 6 and live music Thursday through Saturday. The food is Keys seafood without a lot of fuss.
ReelCatch at Amara Cay Resort is part of Taste the Keys for October 2026, the Key Largo Chamber of Commerce's month of prix-fixe menus at Upper Keys restaurants. Dinner at ReelCatch is $45, and there's a $25 lunch at the resort's Tiki Bar. Tax and tip are extra. The rest of the lineup is in our October in the Keys guide.
Address
80001 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
Phone
(305) 664-0073Website
Visit WebsiteHours
Breakfast daily 7 am to 11 am; dinner daily 5 pm to 10 pm; happy hour 4 pm to 6 pm
Mile Marker
80 Oceanside
Best For
Ocean views, live music on weekends, and resort breakfast.
106 Oceanside“Dock-and-dine on the Manatee Canal in Garden Cove.”
99.5 Bayside“A sunset bar on Florida Bay at mile marker 99.5.”
106.5 Oceanside“A seafood place on the water, tucked one block off US 1.”
