Established in 1976,Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen is the longest-running restaurant in Key Largo and a true “must-stop” on the Overseas Highway. Known for its world-famous Key Lime Pie and license-plate-covered walls, this local legend has grown into two distinct locations to serve both the early-morning crowd and the late-night dinner scene.
Location 1 (The Original): 99336 Overseas Hwy (MM 99.4), Key Largo, FL 33037
Location 2 (Mrs. Mac’s II): 99020 Overseas Hwy (MM 99), Key Largo, FL 33037
Vibe: “Key-easy” rustic charm, historic, and family-oriented.
Contact: (305) 451-3722 |mrsmacskitchen.com
It is important to know which “Mac’s” you are heading to, as they serve different purposes:
Feature | Mrs. Mac’s (The Original) | Mrs. Mac’s II
Best For | Breakfast & Early Lunch | Lunch, Dinner & Cocktails
Hours | Mon–Sat: 7:00 AM – 3:00 PM | Mon–Sat: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Vibe | Historic shack with license plates. | Larger, newer, with a full liquor bar.
Parking | Cozy (limited space) | Ample (easier for larger vehicles)
Whether you’re there for a sunrise breakfast or a sunset dinner, these are the non-negotiables:
World Famous Key Lime Pie: Often cited as the best in the Keys. It’s the perfect balance of tart and sweet with a graham cracker crust.
The Key Lime Freeze: A creamy, frozen citrus treat that is essentially a Key Lime Pie in milkshake form.
Konk Chowder: Their award-winning, tomato-based red chowder is a local staple.
The “Mac Attack”: A legendary breakfast plate featuring two eggs, biscuits with gravy, home fries, and your choice of meat.
The “Jelly” Fishwich: Blackened or grilled Mahi-Mahi on a hoagie roll topped with their signature chili pepper jelly, provolone, and grilled onions.
Sunday Status: Please note thatboth locations are typically closed on Sundays, so plan your visit for a Saturday or a weekday.
Cook Your Catch: If you’ve spent the day with a charter likeFantastic II, bring your cleaned fillets here. They offer several “Cook Your Catch” styles, including blackened, fried, or “T.J. Style” (stewed tomatoes, tomatillos, and jalapeños).
License Plate Tradition: If you visit the Original location, take a moment to look at the thousands of license plates from around the world. It’s a tradition started by the original owner, Jeff Macfarland, and continued today.
The Gift Shop: Mrs. Mac’s II has a robust gift shop where you can buy their world-famous chili, hot sauces, and apparel to take a piece of the Keys home with you.
Insider Tip: If you’re in a rush, you can order a whole Key Lime Pie to go. It makes for the ultimate bribe for your neighbors back home!
106.5 Oceanside“A seafood place on the water, tucked one block off US 1.”
106 Oceanside“Dock-and-dine on the Manatee Canal in Garden Cove.”
99.5 Bayside“A sunset bar on Florida Bay at mile marker 99.5.”
