Established in 1976,Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen is the longest-running restaurant in Key Largo and a true “must-stop” on the Overseas Highway. Known for its world-famous Key Lime Pie and license-plate-covered walls, this local legend has grown into two distinct locations to serve both the early-morning crowd and the late-night dinner scene.
Quick Stats
- Location 1 (The Original): 99336 Overseas Hwy (MM 99.4), Key Largo, FL 33037
- Location 2 (Mrs. Mac’s II): 99020 Overseas Hwy (MM 99), Key Largo, FL 33037
- Vibe: “Key-easy” rustic charm, historic, and family-oriented.
- Contact: (305) 451-3722 |mrsmacskitchen.com
One Name, Two Experiences
It is important to know which “Mac’s” you are heading to, as they serve different purposes:
Feature | Mrs. Mac’s (The Original) | Mrs. Mac’s II
Best For | Breakfast & Early Lunch | Lunch, Dinner & Cocktails
Hours | Mon–Sat: 7:00 AM – 3:00 PM | Mon–Sat: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Vibe | Historic shack with license plates. | Larger, newer, with a full liquor bar.
Parking | Cozy (limited space) | Ample (easier for larger vehicles)
The Menu “Wall of Fame”
Whether you’re there for a sunrise breakfast or a sunset dinner, these are the non-negotiables:
- World Famous Key Lime Pie: Often cited as the best in the Keys. It’s the perfect balance of tart and sweet with a graham cracker crust.
- The Key Lime Freeze: A creamy, frozen citrus treat that is essentially a Key Lime Pie in milkshake form.
- Konk Chowder: Their award-winning, tomato-based red chowder is a local staple.
- The “Mac Attack”: A legendary breakfast plate featuring two eggs, biscuits with gravy, home fries, and your choice of meat.
- The “Jelly” Fishwich: Blackened or grilled Mahi-Mahi on a hoagie roll topped with their signature chili pepper jelly, provolone, and grilled onions.
Local Knowledge & Tips
- Sunday Status: Please note thatboth locations are typically closed on Sundays, so plan your visit for a Saturday or a weekday.
- Cook Your Catch: If you’ve spent the day with a charter likeFantastic II, bring your cleaned fillets here. They offer several “Cook Your Catch” styles, including blackened, fried, or “T.J. Style” (stewed tomatoes, tomatillos, and jalapeños).
- License Plate Tradition: If you visit the Original location, take a moment to look at the thousands of license plates from around the world. It’s a tradition started by the original owner, Jeff Macfarland, and continued today.
- The Gift Shop: Mrs. Mac’s II has a robust gift shop where you can buy their world-famous chili, hot sauces, and apparel to take a piece of the Keys home with you.
Insider Tip: If you’re in a rush, you can order a whole Key Lime Pie to go. It makes for the ultimate bribe for your neighbors back home!
